Gotham Pizza Menu
56 items in 8 sections · $2.00 – $60.00 · Pizza Restaurant in New York, NY
Gotham Pizza’s menu lists 56 dishes and drinks, grouped into Garlic Knots, 12" Pizza Pies, Beverages, Square Pizza Slices, Salads, and 16" Pizza Pies and more. Prices range from $2.00 to $60.00, and a typical item costs about $24.00. Popular choices include 4 Garlic Knots, Regular 12" Pizza With 1 Topping, Bottled Water 16 Oz, Sicilian Slice, and House Salad.
Garlic Knots 1
- 4 Garlic Knots$2.50
Garlic Knots
12" Pizza Pies 17
- Regular 12" Pizza With 1 Topping$20.00
12" pizza, choice of 1: meatballs, sausage, peppers, onions, pepperoni, mushrooms, spinach, anchovies, broccoli, olives, garlic, basil, tomatoes, extra cheese.
- Margherita 12" Pizza With 1 Topping$24.00
Margherita pizza, 12", choice of topping: meatballs, sausage, peppers, onions, pepperoni, mushrooms, spinach, anchovies, broccoli, olives, garlic, basil, tomatoes, extra cheese.
- BBQ Chicken 12" Pizza With 1 Topping$26.00
Bbq chicken on a 12" crust, choice of topping: meatballs, sausage, peppers, onions, pepperoni, mushrooms, spinach, anchovies, broccoli, olives, garlic, basil, tomatoes, extra cheese.
- Chicken Cutlet 12" Pizza With 1 Topping$25.00
Chicken cutlet on 12" crust, choice of topping: meatballs, sausage, peppers, onions, pepperoni, mushrooms, spinach, anchovies, broccoli, olives, garlic, basil, tomatoes, extra cheese.
- 12" Buffalo Chicken Pizza$23.00
12" Buffalo chicken and ranch pizza
- Buffalo Chicken 12" Pizza With 1 Topping$26.00
Buffalo chicken 12" pizza; choose 1: meatballs, sausage, peppers, onions, pepperoni, mushrooms, spinach, anchovies, broccoli, olives, garlic, basil, tomatoes, extra cheese.
- 12" BBQ Chicken Pizza$23.00
BBQ chicken pizza
- 12" White Pizza$21.00
12" Mozzarella cheese, Ricotta cheese and olive oil
- 12" Vegetable Pizza$23.00
12" All vegetables pizza
- 12" Chicken Cutlet Pizza$22.00
12" Chicken cutlet pizza
- White 12" Pizza With 1 Topping$24.00
12" white pizza; choose from meatballs, sausage, peppers, onions, pepperoni, mushrooms, spinach, anchovies, broccoli, olives, garlic, basil, tomatoes, extra cheese.
- Vegetable 12" Pizza With 1 Topping$26.00
12" pizza with choice of topping: meatballs, sausage, peppers, onions, pepperoni, mushrooms, spinach, anchovies, broccoli, olives, garlic, basil, tomatoes, extra cheese.
- Pepperoni 12" Pizza With 1 Topping$23.00
12" pepperoni pizza; choose one: meatballs, sausage, peppers, onions, extra pepperoni, mushrooms, spinach, anchovies, broccoli, olives, garlic, basil, tomatoes, extra cheese.
- 12" Pepperoni Pizza$20.00
12" Pepperoni pizza
- 12" Margherita Pizza$21.00
12" Fresh mozzarella, homemade marinara, fresh basil and olive oil
- 12" House Special Pizza$26.00
- 12" Regular Pizza$17.00
12" Regular cheese pizza
Beverages 3
- Bottled Water 16 Oz$2.00
Poland Spring
- 2 Liter Soda$5.00
Coke, Diet Coke and Sprite
- 12 Oz Soda Can$2.00
Choose from coke, diet coke, sprite, ginger ale, fanta orange. 12 oz serving.
Square Pizza Slices 2
- Sicilian Slice$3.75
- Grandma Pizza Slice$4.50
Homemade marinara sauce, mozzarella, extra virgin olive oil and fresh basil.
Salads 4
- House Salad$8.00
Romaine lettuce, tomatoes, cucumber, black olives, onions and carrots. Light-italian dressing on the side.
- Party Size Caesar Salad$60.00
Serves 8-10 people.
- Party Size House Salad$50.00
Serves 8-10 people.
- Caesar Salad$9.00
Romaine lettuce, fresh romano cheese, cucumbers and croutons. Caesar dressing on the side.
16" Pizza Pies 17
- 16" Margherita Pizza$28.00
Fresh mozzarella, homemade marinara sauce, extra virgin olive oil and fresh basil.
- Regular 16" Pizza With 1 Topping$27.00
Regular pizza.
- 16" House Special Pizza$33.00
Everything on it!.
- 16" White Pizza$28.00
Mozzarella cheese, ricotta cheese and olive oil
- 16" Vegetable Pizza$30.00
All vegetable pizza
- 16" Regular Pizza$23.00
Regular cheese pizza
- Vegetable 16" Pizza With 1 Topping$34.00
All vegetables pizza.
- White 16" Pizza With 1 Topping$32.00
Mozzarella and ricotta cheese.
- Buffalo Chicken 16" Pizza With 1 Topping$34.00
Buffalo chicken and ranch pizza.
- 16" Pepperoni Pizza$27.00
Pepperoni pizza.
- 16" Buffalo Chicken Pizza$30.00
Buffalo chicken with ranch pizza.
- Chicken Cutlet 16" Pizza With 1 Topping$33.00
Chicken cutlet pizza.
- Margherita 16" Pizza With 1 Topping$32.00
Fresh mozzarella, homemade marinara sauce, extra virgin olive oil and fresh basil.
- BBQ Chicken 16" Pizza With 1 Topping$34.00
16" bbq chicken pizza. choose one: meatballs, sausage, peppers, onions, pepperoni, mushrooms, spinach, anchovies, broccoli, olives, garlic, basil, tomatoes, extra cheese.
- Pepperoni 16" Pizza With 1 Topping$31.00
Pepperoni pizza.
- 16" BBQ Chicken Pizza$30.00
BBQ chicken cutlet pizza.
- 16" Chicken Cutlet Pizza$29.00
Chicken cutlet pizza.
Square Pizza Pies 4
- Grandma Pizza$27.00
Mozzarella, homemade marinara sauce, extra virgin olive oil and fresh basil
- Sicilian Pizza With 1 Topping$29.00
Sicilian pizza.
- Sicilian Pizza Pie$25.00
Sicilian pizza.
- Grandma Pizza With 1 Topping$31.00
Homemade marinara sauce, mozzarella, extra virgin olive oil and fresh basil.
Pizza Slices 8
- Pepperoni Pizza Slice$4.50
Pepperoni slice.
- Regular Pizza Slice$3.50
Regular cheese slice
- BBQ Chicken Pizza Slice$5.00
BBQ chicken cutlet.
- Vegetable Slice$5.00
All Vegetables
- Buffalo Chicken Pizza Slice$5.00
Buffalo chicken with ranch slice.
- White Pizza Slice$4.50
Mozzarella cheese, ricotta cheese and olive oil
- Margherita Pizza Slice$4.50
Fresh mozzarella, homemade marinara sauce, extra virgin olive oil and fresh basil.
- Chicken Cutlet Pizza Slice$5.00
Chicken cutlet slice.
Menu items and prices are provided for information and may have changed (last updated May 2026). Allergen information is not included – please ask the restaurant.